A chance for Donald to shine?

Please note that ALL content on The Dumbarton Terrace is copyright and may not be reproduced in any form without the author’s prior permission.

EVEN as a completely meaningless fixture, Dumbarton’s game with Raith Rovers on Saturday has one big question in advance.

Will Donald McCallum, scorer of two goals in only 26 minutes of first-team football, get his first start for Sons?

He only turned 18 in September, and has spent most of the season playing for the club’s under-20 side.

But why not? If he did well to get a goal in only his second game as a sub, against Livingston in January, what about Saturday?

Ten minutes from the end of the match against Queen of the South, Sons trailed 2-0 when Mark Gilhaney played the ball to Donald from the right.

The young substitute’s finish was as clinical as that of a seasoned goalscorer, and led to calls for him to start against Raith.

However, the teenager insists he’ll be happy just to get a run-out as Dumbarton take on the managerless Kirkcaldy side.

He told The Dumbarton Terrace: “It was brilliant to get another goal. I’ve only played about 26 minutes in total for the first team and to have scored twice in that time is great.

“It was especially good to score against Queen of the South as they are a good side. I was just happy to get a bit of game time, but to score was a real bonus. It’s just a pity about the result.

“Garry Fleming was injured so when I looked at the bench I thought I would get on at some point, and I was preparing myself as a result.

“I’ve done alright with the under-20s this season and I thought I did alright when I came on at Dumfries as well.

“I think everyone will be hoping for a start in the last game of the season on Saturday. If I could even get about 25-30 minutes on the pitch that would be fine.

“But it would be good to get some game time. Raith are not going for anything and neither are we, but hopefully it will still be a good game.

“I’m not sure what to expect from it. We’ve beaten them 2-1 and they’ve beaten us 2-1, and with their manager leaving you don’t know what can happen.

“The manager just said well done to me after my goal. He hasn’t given anything away about who will play on Saturday yet.

“We’ll be training tomorrow night, so hopefully I can do well during that session and we’ll see what happens from there.”

Donald’s introduction at Dumfries was one half of a double change by Sons, which saw fellow under-20 prospect Ryan Clark make his first team debut.

The duo were put into the action after a fine season with the under-20 squad – with a highlight being Donald’s recent five-goal haul against Annan Athletic.

He can still play for the development squad in the 2015/16 campaign, but is waiting to see if a more established first team place awaits him.

Donald continued: “Ryan has deserved it. He’s done really well with the under-20s this season even though he came in a bit after the season started.

“It was good to see him getting his first team debut and there are a few young players who could also make it.

“I don’t really know what’s going to happen in the next few weeks. Nothing has been spoken about and if I get some game time this weekend, and possibly score, you don’t know what can happen.

“I would hope to get a contract with the first team but I’ve still got another year to play under-20 football.”

As the development side’s season is now over, Donald’s boots can be hung up for a few weeks after Saturday whatever happens.

The Sons Supporters Trust awards night will round off the term, but the teenager added: “I don’t think I’m going to the awards bash, but I’ll see what’s happening!

“The under-20s had their final game of the season at Annan last week. We lost 4-2 but they had about five or six first team players out while we were all under-20s.

“I’m looking forward to a break after Saturday. I’ll just be working and going to the gym and keeping myself fit before pre-season starts.”

Queen of the South 2 Dumbarton 1

Please note that ALL content on The Dumbarton Terrace is copyright and may not be reproduced in any form without the author’s prior permission.

THE entire starting XI had scored 15 league goals between them all season.

And in the end, it took a newly-introduced substitute, who at that point had played 16 minutes of first-team football, to get Dumbarton on the scoresheet.

Kind of sums it up.

This was by no means a poor performance by Sons against Queen of the South, even though they trailed 2-0 to goals by Kevin Holt and Steve McKenna.

They were determined, they were battle-hardened and let the promotion chasers know that the points they needed to secure promotion were going to be won the hard way.

What they lacked was any goal threat, until Donald McCallum picked up Mark Gilhaney’s low ball and scored with 10 minutes to go.

The youngster’s finish was as clinical as anything Sons have produced this season. He has to start against Raith Rovers on Saturday in what is the definitive meaningless fixture.

As a youth player, he doesn’t have contract talks to think about next week. Apart from fellow youngster Ryan Clark, who made his first-team debut as a sub, and the on-loan players, the rest of Sons’ squad on Saturday do.

And unfortunately, this was more evidence of why Ian Murray has some difficult decisions ahead.

The gaffer was already without team captain Andy Graham through suspension. Injury also robbed him of the services of top scorer Garry Fleming.

Although there were few chances for Sons in the first half, the same could be said of their hosts, who found them difficult to break down at times.

In saying that, Danny Rogers’ close range save from Derek Lyle’s header on 13 minutes was quite something. The striker looked set to put away Holt’s cross only to be denied by a remarkable stop.

Mitch Megginson was played in on goal by Scott Agnew’s through ball, but the home keeper turned his effort wide. Then close to half time, Rogers was again on form, saving from Gavin Reilly.

That was really it for the first half. Unfortunately for Sons, 11 minutes was all they could hold out for after the restart.

Ian McShane sent a high ball into the area and Holt met it at the back post for a straightforward finish.

Soon after that, Michael Paton’s shot from the corner of the area was cleared off the line by Scott Linton.

Stuart Findlay was unlucky with a header on 69 minutes which was turned over the bar by the keeper.

But three minutes later it looked done and dusted. A corner was only partly cleared, and McKenna fired home through a crowded area.

Murray sent on two of four youth players on the bench – and with 10 minutes remaining, McCallum made a name for himself again.

Gilhaney played him in with a low ball from the right wing and, after advancing to the edge of the area, the youngster applied a composed low finish.

Five minutes later both he and Clark were well-placed when Archie Campbell broke into the area. However, the striker went for goal himself and blasted over.

Gilhaney’s shot was deflected into the side netting as it looked increasingly like Sons could snatch a point, which wouldn’t have been altogether undeserved.

However, Queens can just as easily say they could have won it with a minute remaining, as Lewis Kidd was put through but shot past.

This was Sons’ fifth defeat in a row, but of that sequence, only the Hibs game can match it performance-wise.

Raith Rovers head to the Rock on Saturday on a losing run of exactly the same length.

Dead rubber or not, in a season where the goal was achieved with six games to go, the chance is there for Sons to go out on a high.

Queen of the South: Atkinson; Holt, Dowie, Durnan, Higgins, Reilly (Pickard 90), Russell (Paton 10), McKenna, Carmichael, McShane, Lyle (Kidd 83). Subs: Arthur; Hooper, D Smith, A Smith. Booked: Carmichael.

Dumbarton: Rogers; Linton, Turner, Agnew, Megginson (D McCallum 76), Kirkpatrick (Gilhaney 65), Taggart, Petrie (Clark 76), Findlay, Campbell, Wilson. Subs: Ewings; Van Zanten, C McCallum, Whitefield. Booked: Turner.

Referee: Brian Colvin.

Crowd: 1,865.

Andy Graham: Q&A

Please note that ALL content on The Dumbarton Terrace is copyright and may not be reproduced in any form without the author’s prior permission.

IT is the day before Andy Graham has to do something he’s not done for over two years.

Tomorrow, due to a one-match ban, the Dumbarton skipper will be sitting in the stand watching his team-mates play Queen of the South.

He did miss Sons’ 3-0 defeat to Hibs in February, but spent that afternoon in a maternity ward as his wife gave birth.

But the captain will be back to lead Dumbarton in next week’s dead rubber against Raith Rovers, which brings down the curtain on season 2014/15.

And there is plenty to think about as he takes questions from the fans.

What is your assessment of the season just ended, both on a personal and team level?

Personally I’ve enjoyed it as we’ve done well, and from a team perspective we’ve achieved our goal pretty early this time around. To do that with six games remaining was quite an achievement, especially with the teams who came into the league. I know our form has been poor recently but looking back over the season, to be safe with that many games left is something we haven’t done at all in our time at this level. It’s maybe not been as free-flowing as it was last year but the main thing is that we are in the Championship for another season.

What’s been your personal highlight?

Scoring first at Ibrox in January was quite special and something that I will not forget – it doesn’t matter that it was a two-yard toe-poke! For the team, the highlight of the season would probably be drawing 0-0 with Hearts in the first home game against them. We were really good that day and unlucky not to actually win it. Hearts have only failed to score twice in the league all season and for us to be one of the teams to stop them was good for us.

At the start, would you have thought it possible that consolidation in the Championship with six games remaining would be a realistic achievement, bearing in mind the strength of the division?

I don’t think we could have seen that and if you’d asked any fan who was honest enough I don’t think they would either. If you’d said we’d do it with six games to go no-one would have believed you. We knew it would be hard going at times because of the nature of the teams we were playing against but it’s a good achievement to do what we’ve done. We’ve been frustrated by how we’ve been doing recently but looking at the season as a whole, it’s something to be proud of.

How do you feel about the record against Hearts, Hibernian and Rangers this season – would it have been nice to beat one of them?

Definitely. We’ve drawn with Hibs and Hearts but didn’t take anything off Rangers, which is a big frustration for us. We have played well in some of the games against them – the Scottish Cup tie, which we lost 1-0, definitely stands out. But they are not the games that keep you in the league – those are the ones against the likes of Alloa, Cowdenbeath and Raith Rovers. Alloa have had some great games against Rangers this season but I’m happy with where we are in the league and I wouldn’t want to swap positions with them.

What has been your opinion of the 3-5-2 formation which has been used this season?

It’s something we haven’t really used in the past and this year the manager thought at certain times it would pay off for us. I can’t remember how many times we’ve played it now, maybe six or seven, and sometimes it’s worked and sometimes it hasn’t. Sometimes it gets put down to formations but for me it’s an excuse that people hide behind. We’ve just not been good enough in some games and it doesn’t matter whether we’ve played 3-5-2, 4-4-2 or whatever formation – we just haven’t turned up. We’ve looked more comfortable with four at the back but it’s the manager’s decision what way we set out. Being part-time, it is difficult to work on shape, while if you are full-time, you have the facilities and time to work on it, which we don’t have. That’s a major factor.

Has there been a problem with motivation since survival was secured at the end of March?

To be fair, we haven’t done ourselves justice in the last few games, particularly the ones at Cowdenbeath and Alloa. Those are the ones that stick in my throat and the other players’ throats because were really poor in those. Hibs and Rangers took care of themselves because we are always going to be up for those games and that showed in our performances. Maybe there is an element of ‘that’s us safe now’ but it’s no excuse. We certainly didn’t go off the pitch at Cowdenbeath or Alloa thinking ‘we lost 3-0, no big deal’ – we were frustrated not just for ourselves but also for the fans. We also had a proud record against Alloa and it’s really frustrating to lose that. Hopefully in the last two games we can improve.

The night is approaching when players are told whether they are part of Ian Murray’s plans for next season. Will you be staying at the club if offered a deal?

I’ve thoroughly enjoyed my three seasons here and enjoyed my football, and if the manager wants to keep me I’ll be really happy. However, no-one has spoken about it yet, so I’m not being presumptuous about it. Sometimes clubs go down different routes but I’m hopeful I can stay and that the gaffer will want to keep hold of me. There’s a core group of us who have kept us in the division over the last two to three years and hopefully we can sit down in the coming weeks and get things sorted for next season. We want to do that for our own futures and I’m sure the manager wants that as well – the sooner he hears back from players the sooner he can go out and look forward to next season.

You’ve been released in the past, from Hamilton Accies 2011. How does it feel to have a manager tell you that you’re not in his plans and how do you bounce back?

It’s never nice – that was the only time it’s happened to me, and in fairness I knew it was coming. I’d played 17 games up to February and then due to circumstances I didn’t play again after that, so it came as no surprise. It was amicable because I wanted something different. There’s always a feeling of whether you could have done better and you do have the self-doubt, but mentally you have to stay strong. You see it so many times – Paul McGinn is a perfect example. He came back a level to play for Dumbarton, got his head completely right and now he’s flourishing in the Premiership with Dundee. It took a lot of mental strength for him to play part-time at Dumbarton and it’s paid off for him.

If not yourself, then who do you think will win the player and young player of the year awards next Saturday night?

Certainly not me anyway! There are a good few in with a shout – Danny Rogers will certainly be in there. As he’s eligible for young player of the year, I’ll go for him with that award. He’s had a really good season and I think he’ll win one or two awards. I’m not sure what’s happening with him at Aberdeen but I’d be surprised if they didn’t offer him another year after the season he’s had with us. He could also win player of the year, but it could also be Garry Fleming or Scott Agnew, who has had a great season. Mark Gilhaney has done consistently well and you could be looking at any from those four. Garry is one of the hardest to play against in the league when he is on his game. Any of those four would deserve it.

What about the divisional player of the year, out of nominees Scott Allan, Morgaro Gomis, Alim Ozturk and Jamie Walker?

I think Scott Allan will probably win it. He’s had a really good season and you’ve seen the difference in him in our games against Hibs. When we played them in the cup game he’d just signed for them and looked a bit sluggish, but by the next time we played them he was in really good shape. His training has paid off and he’s been brilliant for Hibs. It’s strange for Hearts to dominate the league and then someone else wins player of the year, but he’s been a standout. If it’s not him then Jamie Walker has been a big player for Hearts and could be in with a chance.

Who do you think will win promotion out of Hibernian, Rangers and Queen of the South, if any?

None of them. Hibs have the best chance based on the games we’ve played against them, and I think they’ll be in the final, but people seem to be writing the Premiership team off – all the talk’s been about Hibs and Rangers. Queen of the South are a right good side and that’s shown in some of their results, but the Premier team has the advantage of not having the run of games. I think that will tell.

Which of Alloa, Cowdenbeath and Livingston do you think will go down?

There’s a question! It’s hard because Alloa play Cowdenbeath on the last day of the season and it will really boil down to that. Because of that fixture, Livingston might end up squeezing out of bottom place and if they do, I think they will win the play-offs. If results go Queen of the South’s way tomorrow, and they clinch fourth place, then they could have one eye on that when they go to Livingston next week. As for Alloa and Cowdenbeath, I honestly have no idea!

And out of Stranraer, Morton, Forfar and Brechin, which (potentially) two would you like to see come up?

Obviously I was a Morton fan growing up and I’ve always liked playing at Cappielow. However, from Dumbarton’s point of view you’re looking for another part-time side to come up. That gives you another team to look to finish ahead of next year and it’s what we would want. We don’t have a great record against Stranraer so I’ll go with Forfar and Brechin!

Theoretically, the Championship line-up next season could be Motherwell, St Mirren, Hibs, Rangers, Falkirk, Raith Rovers, Livingston and Morton, along with Dumbarton and one other part-time team. How much would you relish being in that division?

It’d be fantastic – it’s why you play football, to play at the stadiums of these clubs. And all it can do is attract better players to the club. The fans will enjoy the days out at venues they are not used to going to. At the same time it would present a massive challenge, but it’s one we will be looking forward to whoever comes up or down.

As a boyhood Morton fan, how much are you looking forward to (likely) playing against St Mirren next season?

I’d love it if I’m being honest. I’ve only played against St Mirren once, and that wasn’t even in national competitions – it was the Renfrewshire Cup final. I fractured my cheekbone 12 minutes into the game and played on until half time, but by then I didn’t know whether it was New Year or New York, and came off. That was a disappointment for me and I’d love to play against them again, in a competitive game.

Who is the best player you have played alongside in your career?

I’d probably say Robert Snodgrass, when he came on loan to Stirling Albion. He was fantastic and you could tell that if he got his head right, he’d go on to be a class act.  It was crazy that he came on loan to Stirling – we all saw him and wondered what was going on. He made a massive difference in Stirling getting promoted through the play-offs.

And the best young player (aged under 21)? Where do Danny Rogers and Stuart Findlay rank in that?

They’ve come in and done really well but the best young player I’ve played alongside would probably be Chris Kane! You saw the difference he made not only last year, but this season – he only played about seven games but he still managed five goals. In training you wouldn’t think he was the same player because he’s quite laid back – but I’ve never seen a young player come on loan and work as hard as he did. Danny and Stuart have big futures in the game – no doubt about that. Stuart’s pace as a centre half is ridiculous and coming on loan to Dumbarton is going to help him. He needs to play competitive games and he and Danny have a big chance.

Dumbarton 1 Rangers 3

Please note that ALL content on The Dumbarton Terrace is copyright and may not be reproduced in any form without the author’s prior permission.

FOURTEEN chances they’ve had.

Opportunities to put themselves on the map in a Championship season like no other.

But Dumbarton will end the season without having recorded any famous victories against Rangers, Hearts or Hibernian.

And the sequence ended on a day when the final chance simply passed them by.

It started with a bang when Mark Wilson opened the scoring. Even with Ryan Hardie having equalised for a young Gers side, Sons were still in the game at half time.

However, the reset button was pressed at the interval. They went straight back to the team they’d been the last two Saturdays.

After Hardie got his second, and Haris Vuckic made it 3-1 – both of them fine strikes – there was nothing. No indication that Sons could get back into the game.

In the end, only some outstanding goalkeeping by Danny Rogers prevented Rangers from winning even more easily.

And perhaps the most disappointing thing?

This may have been the last chance for some players to prove themselves worthy of new deals.

After all, what is there for manager Ian Murray to learn from a trip to a Queen of the South side with one foot, and some of the other, already in the play-offs?

Or a home game with Raith Rovers which has been such a dead rubber for some weeks that rigor mortis is setting in?

Rangers could be back at the Rock next season. St Mirren almost certainly will be, and they might be joined by Hibernian and Motherwell if Queen of the South win the play-offs.

There could be another four full-time sides next season – Falkirk, Raith Rovers, Livingston and Morton. This division could be even harder.

Whether that is the line-up, or Sons have a different variation to contend with, they need to strengthen. Murray has some major, major decisions ahead in a fortnight’s time.

And he has to be ruthless. There has to be no room for under-performers.

Wilson scored the winner for Celtic against Rangers four years ago, in a Scottish Cup tie. After two minutes, it looked like he could have done a similar deed for Dumbarton.

Mark Gilhaney sent over a cross and after a defender flicked it on, the ball was thrashed in by the former Hoops man.

Sons were now in the same position that they held for seven minutes at Ibrox in January. This time around, they held the lead for nine minutes.

Hardie, making his first start for Rangers, ran on to a long ball and despite Stuart Findlay’s manful efforts to clear, did enough to force the ball over the line after beating Rogers.

The keeper, who had already turned Lee McCulloch’s header over the bar, did likewise with Darren McGregor’s 20-yard shot soon afterwards.

But Sons still weren’t out of it and after Dylan Easton broke from the halfway line, his low finish from the edge of the area was sliced wide.

Rogers was again on form during what remained of the first half, saving brilliantly from Nicky Law’s 15-yard shot and, right on half time, denying Vuckic at close range.

However, you need that sort of luck to secure a result. And there was still hope, as the teams disappeared down the tunnel at half time, that Sons could get it.

Then, within seven second half minutes, that optimism was ended.

Three minutes after the restart, Lee Wallace crossed from the left and Hardie, with an overhead volley, found the net.

Then Vuckic blasted in a shot from 25 yards. An afternoon which promised so much was on the brink of collapse.

A Findlay header from Archie Campbell’s free kick at least looked like finding the net, but his effort was saved.

The reality was that Rangers were winning in third gear.

Hardie missed out on his hat-trick with a lobbed shot from the edge of the area, while Law’s shot from the edge of the area hit the bar.

The ball rebounded back into play, with substitute Calum Gallagher shooting over from six yards.

Nicky Clark went for a 40-yard volley as the final whistle beckoned, but his shot was narrowly over.

For Sons, it just was not to be. But giving a decent account of yourselves for 45 minutes doesn’t get a result from this match for a part-time side.

It has to be the A game for the full 90 minutes – and that just wasn’t there.

Over the season’s final 180 minutes, all the fans can ask is that the best efforts and performances are provided. And who knows, there may be some points left in it for Sons.

But for some, it could be too late.

Dumbarton: Rogers; Graham, Gilhaney (Linton 82), Agnew, Kirkpatrick, Taggart, Fleming, Easton (Megginson 73), Findlay, Campbell, Wilson. Subs: Ewings; McCallum, Petrie, Lightbody. Booked: Megginson, Graham.

Rangers: Bell; Wallace, McCulloch, Law, Vuckic (Black 86), Clark, McGregor, Zaliukas, Murdoch, Walsh, Hardie (Gallagher 86). Subs: Simonsen; Mohsni, Boyd, Crawford, Shiels.

Referee: Craig Thomson.

Crowd: 1,770.

Ten reasons why Dumbarton CAN beat Rangers

Please note that ALL content on The Dumbarton Terrace is copyright and may not be reproduced in any form without the author’s prior permission.

SO, on to business.

Dumbarton. The best part-time team in Scotland for a third year in a row. And the side who, on the last two Saturdays, haven’t really turned up to face teams below them in the table.

In between came an excellent display against Hibernian which deserved far more than it got.

That was against one promotion-chasing team known throughout Scotland. Tomorrow, they face another such game.

Rangers come to the Rock with their play-off place already clinched. But they want second place.

And there’s nothing at stake for Dumbarton to get in the way of that, right?

Aye.

Two big boxes have already been ticked for Sons this season – survival and the best part-time team title.

However, there is still one more. A victory against Hearts, Hibs or Rangers. The three reasons why the Championship has been in such a spotlight this season.

It’s been close, but no cigar on a few occasions. But still the victory remains elusive.

To achieve it tomorrow will take a stellar performance from everyone in white/day-glo orange. It’ll also take confidence all around the Sons camp that it CAN be done.

And if that manifests itself, who knows what can happen?

TEN REASONS WHY SONS CAN WIN TOMORROW

1. Due a result against a high-profile club

In 13 games against the ‘big three’ this season, there haven’t been many where Dumbarton have really done themselves a disservice. Against Hearts a 0-0 draw was fully merited in the first meeting while the two trips at Tynecastle, while deservedly won by the Jambos, were by harsh margins. The only time Sons have really looked out of their depth against the champions was the 5-1 defeat at the Rock in January, and even then the wind had a massive say that day. Over five games against Hibernian, again they have taken a 0-0 draw which was merited, and there have been at least two games lost to the Easter Road club which deserved better. The recent 2-1 reverse at home was unfair, as was the 3-2 defeat which saw them exit the League Cup at the second round stage. But…

2. Gradually improving against Rangers

Although Dumbarton have been by no means bad across the board against Rangers this season, there’s just a feeling that they still have more to offer when they play the Ibrox club. The first two games against them resulted in a 4-1 defeat at Ibrox and a 3-0 loss at home – neither scoreline could be argued with. Then there was the 1-0 Scottish Cup third round defeat which saw a much closer affair between the sides. And for seven minutes in Govan in January, Sons led through an Andy Graham goal. Chances were missed later in the game to take at least a draw and the goal which sealed a 3-1 win for Rangers was on a counter attack. Having gradually improved in games against Rangers this season, can Sons carry it on?

3. They owe the fans a performance

The 3-0 defeat at Cowdenbeath at the start of April was followed by a response which deserved much better – the aforementioned 2-1 game at home to Hibs. So after another lifeless 3-0 loss, against Alloa last Saturday, go figure. Putting in performances like those on consecutive Saturdays do not sit well with Dumbarton, or the fans, who the squad will surely feel they owe a display this weekend. And more often than not, when Sons owe a performance, they deliver.

4. ALL the pressure is on Rangers

Despite the appointment of Stuart McCall as manager, and a fairly successful start, the honeymoon period doesn’t look like it has lasted at Ibrox. Rangers don’t lose many – last week’s 3-0 defeat at Queen of the South is the only one lost under the new management so far. However, going back even further than McCall’s appointment, the Gers have won away from home only four times since their 1-0 victory at the Rock in November. And…

5. All three teams below Sons in the Championship have taken points off Rangers

Alloa were first, doing so with a 1-1 draw at the Indodrill Stadium on Saturday, September 20, and they have since repeated the trick on both of their visits to Ibrox. There was also, of course, that unforgettable night in Clackmannanshire when they fought back from 2-0 down with 20 minutes to go to knock Rangers out of the Petrofac Training Cup. Cowdenbeath, a week after their 10-0 hammering at Tynecastle, secured a 0-0 draw with Rangers at Central Park last month, while Livingston have taken a point off Rangers at home and away. If the three teams still battling to avoid the drop can get results, why can’t a side which has secured survival with six games left?

6. Improvement in results at home

In the last two months, only Hibernian have left the Rock having claimed all three points as the away side. That was with Sons having played the final half hour with 10 men, and with many of them having spent a full day at work as ‘preparation’ for the game, while the Edinburgh side rested up. Two other promotion chasers, Queen of the South and Falkirk (although the latter’s challenge is fading), have failed to win or score at the Rock in that spell. Four positive home performances, if not results, don’t necessarily mean a corner has been turned, but is the Rock gradually becoming Sons’ fortress again?

7. Danny Rogers will be in goal

Danny Rogers has already saved penalties from all of the big three this season – keeping out the likes of Gennero Zeefuik, Farid El Alagui and Dominique Malonga. He also denied Lee McCulloch from the spot when Rangers last visited on league business in October. Even allowing for the presence of established keepers like Neil Alexander, the on-loan Aberdeen man is rated by many among the best keepers in the league. If the Dons do not give him a chance in the first team when he returns then they must have some very high quality keepers in their ranks. And if that is the case, he’d be most welcome back at Dumbarton.

8. Lucky referee?

Having a particular referee in charge doesn’t guarantee results, of course. And technically it was a Dumbarton select against a Rangers XI. However, in July 2006, Craig Thomson was the man in the middle when a team of Sons players beat a team of Rangers players 1-0, with John Gemmell scoring the game’s only goal. On Saturday Mr Thomson will be the whistler again, assisted by Graeme Leslie and Alan Hogg. He has also been the referee for other big games which have ended successfully for Sons, such as the 3-0 win over Peterhead in the penultimate match of the 2001/02 promotion season. Mr Thomson also oversaw the 0-0 draw at Arbroath which put Sons through to the 2011/12 First Division play-off final.

9. Lucky date?

The last three times Dumbarton have played during the day on April 18, at least two of them have seen significant results achieved. The most recent was in 2009, when they battled out a satisfactory if frustrating goalless draw at title rivals Cowdenbeath, with Stevie Murray missing a penalty. Having beaten Albion Rovers 2-0 on that date in 1998 (only the second home win all season and the last victory of the ‘worst team in Scotland’ campaign), April 18 was also the day when Cowden were beaten 2-1 at Boghead in 1992. That was the result that gave Sons the Second Division title ahead of the Blue Brazil. Sons also played on April 18 2006, losing 2-0 at home to Gretna – with manager Paul Martin declaring that evening as a damage limitation exercise. Surely Ian Murray will not do so tomorrow?

10. Simply because they’re capable

Keep saying it – Dumbarton have a team which is capable of delivering a result in this game. This, after all, is still the nucleus of the squad which, one week ahead of this time last year, dismantled Hamilton Accies on the day the New Douglas Park men could have won the league title. Playing its ‘A’ game, which is due to show up a few more times before this season is out, Dumbarton are capable of being a match for anyone in this division. Ask Hearts, ask Hibs, ask Queen of the South, ask Falkirk. All have dropped points to Sons this season and all except the Hibees have done so at the Rock. There’s just one promotion-chasing side left…

AND FIVE REASONS WHY IT WILL BE DIFFICULT

1. Full-time/part-time divide

Always pointed to when things don’t go to plan in this sort of game, Rangers probably spend more time training together in a day than Dumbarton do in a week. They will also bring several high-profile players to the Rock tomorrow, while for Dumbarton…

2. Chris Turner is suspended

There’s no denying that the midfielder will be a big miss tomorrow. As if to compound it for the boyhood Rangers fan, this means he’ll have failed to start any of the three home matches against the Ibrox club this season, having missed the first altogether and come on as a sub with 21 minutes left of the Scottish Cup tie. The likes of Garry Fleming and Darren Petrie will have an especially key role tomorrow.

3. Rangers need the result more than Dumbarton do

Rangers will definitely be in the play-offs after the season finishes, but are still looking to finish second. Anything other than a win tomorrow and they are looking down the barrel of finishing third, which means two extra play-off fixtures, probably against Queen of the South.

4. The last two Saturday performances

Quite simply if the displays against Alloa and Cowdenbeath are repeated, Sons do not stand a chance tomorrow. But surely, with a famous result at stake, there will be none of that?

5. Where are the goals going to come from?

As Fleming is top scorer with six goals, it’s hardly been a vintage season upfront for Sons. However, just get the ball over the line once tomorrow and as long as Rangers don’t do likewise, it’ll be enough.

BUT THE BIGGEST FACTOR TOWARDS WINNING TOMORROW…

Is a positive ethos around the stadium, from dressing room to stand. Nobody is denying the difficulty of the task, but nobody should be turning up tomorrow accepting defeat or simply looking to say that they say Rangers at the Rock. Last season Dumbarton took on Hamilton off the back of a morale-sapping 3-0 defeat to Queen of the South – and beat the potential champions 4-1. The biggest reason for that? Everyone had confidence that it could be done in spite of the odds against Sons.

That confidence will be needed tomorrow. Some people might still be in doubt about how Dumbarton have achieved the title of Scotland’s best part-time club for a third year in a row.

Tomorrow, they CAN be shown why.

Bonnie Prince Charlie

Please note that ALL content on The Dumbarton Terrace is copyright and may not be reproduced in any form without the author’s prior permission.

IT is a sunny afternoon in Helensburgh, and there is an appointment to be kept with a personnel officer.

One of us is armed with a list of questions. The other has a strong CV.

Naturally, there are nerves. Who wouldn’t be as the personnel officer, suited and booted, comes down the stairs to welcome you for an interview?

And when you are in the presence of a man who is so highly thought of throughout the local area?

Who 20 years ago this year, was part of an extraordinary event?

In order to avoid any spoilers for those who don’t want them, comments on ‘Forthbank day’ will remain a guarded secret for the time being.

But that’s alright. There’s lots else to discuss with the man with whom I am sitting in a warm, one-windowed office.

Especially as, 25 years ago this season, Charlie Gibson became Dumbarton’s record signing. He still holds that title to this day, and probably will for many years to come.

Five years after his £50,000 transfer from Stirling Albion, he was part of the fixture against the Binos which still lives in the memory.

His was the name the fans sang all afternoon, such was the hero status he’d built up at Boghead.

He hasn’t been forgotten about – and in return, he hasn’t forgotten about his former club.

Charlie, now 53, said: “I was in touch with Gilbert Lawrie a while ago. One of my friend’s clients mentioned that his son had been released by Aberdeen and was trying to find a new club.

“I ran Duntocher Boys’ Club for about 10 years, so I didn’t have the same contacts, but I knew Gilbert from my time at Dumbarton.

“He mentioned that I was welcome to come down any time. I’ve always meant to visit and watch a game, but have never been able to.

“The last time I was at the stadium was for a charity game in 2008. Stuart MacIver phoned me out of the blue and asked if I fancied coming down to play for a team of ex-Sons players against Dukla Pumpherston.

“Guys like Hugh Ward, Jim Meechan and John Bourke played in that game – Hugh scored a spectacular goal. He never did score simple tap-ins.

“I still keep an eye out for Dumbarton’s result every week. They’ll be in the Championship again next season and that’s a success for them.

“When I played you had to hope for a cup draw against Rangers, Hearts or Hibernian. I played for Dumbarton against Rangers three times in cup ties.

“They beat us 5-0 at Hampden on a night when we played with two sweepers. Then we lost 1-0 and 4-1 at Ibrox in the same season.

“I also played for Dumbarton against Manchester United in Alex Wright’s testimonial. There was one goal where Peter Schmeichel threw it to Mark Robins, who set up Mark Hughes to score. They had a goal with three touches of the ball, from one end to the other.

“I’ve got a lot of old programmes in my loft from my time at Dumbarton. My wife keeps telling me to get rid of them!”

As a legendary striker, Charlie had many high-profile partners upfront over his years at Boghead.

He was one of at least four players during ‘Forthbank season’ who could always be relied on for goals, alongside Hugh Ward, Martin Mooney and Colin McKinnon.

But even allowing for those, there are two others colleagues from his Dumbarton days who stand out.

He said: “Martin Mooney was a skilful player; a good finisher and quite strong on the ball. Hugh was always capable of cutting inside and hitting one from 25-30 yards.

“He could also put some good crosses in, which suited me as a striker, as my game was mostly played in the air.

“But the best player I played with at Dumbarton was John McQuade. He was different class when the two of us were there.

“And when I first came to the club, it was me and Stuart MacIver upfront. I think we scored about 44 goals between us in one season.

“After that we were both out of contract and in negotiations with Billy Lamont, who was manager at the time.

“We ended up training just the two of us for a couple of weeks before we signed on the dotted line, but it was good times there. Dick Jackson was always around as the groundsman – he was great.

“When I first signed for Dumbarton, manager Jim George introduced me to the players and then said that I could meet the most important person. That was Dick.”

Charlie stayed at Dumbarton for one further year after ‘Forthbank day’ before the time came to say farewell.

He continued: “I spoke to Jim Fallon about my future in the early 1996/97 season. At the time, my son was four and my daughter was nearly one.

“I said that I’d already been around Scotland – at the time, I think I’d played on every ground that existed in the Scottish Football League. I wasn’t keen to keep travelling all over the country as I had a young family.

“Jim said that if I hung about I would maybe play more sparingly, but I still thought I could play regularly.

“When I lived in Old Kilpatrick I would jump on the team bus at the boulevard and go to places like Berwick or Cowdenbeath, or wherever Dumbarton were playing. I no longer wanted to do that every second Saturday.

“The result was that I left the club. Looking back on it now, I sometimes wonder if I did the right thing.”

But even though he was 35 at the time of his departure from Boghead, his days in football weren’t over altogether.

A career in the juniors was to enable him to see out a few more years of a career which, along with spells at Dumbarton and Stirling, also took in East Stirlingshire and Clydebank.

Charlie said: “I played at junior level for a further four seasons. Jim George, who brought me to Dumbarton, was managing Petershill when I left Boghead and took me there.

“I had actually thought about giving up altogether when that came about, but sometimes you go with your gut and I ended up playing until I was nearly 40.

“There was one game against Rutherglen Glencairn, in the middle of December, where I was standing thinking to myself ‘What am I doing here?’. But overall I enjoyed it.

“After I hung up my boots I spent some time helping the Petershill management as part of the coaching staff.

“They also wanted me to go and scout future opponents, but I was more about being around the dressing room on a matchday. I just called it quits from there.”

And as it turned out, Charlie wasn’t finished being a part of Sons’ history either.

On the last day at Boghead in May 2000, he received arguably the loudest cheer of the day as part of a parade of former players.

Perhaps it was even louder than the ones which greeted goals by Toby King and Joe Robertson which gave Sons a 2-1 win over East Fife.

Charlie recalled of the old place: “The last day at Boghead was the end of an era. There was a whole crowd of us down that day.

“It was never the greatest park, but it was home to Dumbarton. When I first joined the club we were top of the league – and then the pitch had problems which meant we didn’t have a home game for months.

“Had it not been for the resulting fixture pile-up we might have won promotion, or even the title, that year.”

So with the playing boots hung up, did moving into management appeal?

It did for a time, but after a spell working with a youth football team, Charlie discovered that sometimes, being in charge isn’t all it’s cracked up to be.

He said: “I did think about a career in coaching or management and I did my qualifications, but that was more for youth football.

“I enjoyed working with my youth team, but when players get to under-17 level or thereabouts other things take over in life.

“I was doing it all voluntarily and the team was quite successful, but my son stopped playing and I decided that was it for me as well.

“To be a manager these days, you need qualifications, but not necessarily the ones you get at Inverclyde.

“I remember Neil Watt, who I played alongside at East Stirlingshire, getting the Stranraer job without any qualifications and doing really well.

“Sometimes these qualifications complicate football. It’s about getting the ball through the goal as often as you can.

“My team-mates would say about me that I wasn’t the most skilful player, but I could hold the ball up or flick it on for my strike partner.

“I watched Rangers beat Hibs recently and they did it through sheer hard work. There’s a lot more science involved in the game now and it’s totally different.”

Charlie is now personnel officer with Argyll and Bute Community Health Partnership, at whose Helensburgh headquarters we are meeting.

But he’s still involved in sport in West Dunbartonshire, as an independent director with the area’s leisure trust.

He added: “My job is to provide direction to the leisure trust on how to move forward. Former referee Kenny Clark was previously a director but stood down.

“Someone mentioned the post to me when they saw it advertised. I chatted with general manager John Anderson and applied successfully. It’s a voluntary role but it’s really interesting to help out and see how the local facilities are delivered.

“Having played for Dumbarton and Clydebank, I had an affinity with the area.”

And 20 years on from ‘Forthbank day’, there are many Sons fans who still have an affinity with their team’s former number nine.

Charlie’s recollections of ‘Forthbank day’ will feature in a special edition of ‘Sons View’, Dumbarton’s matchday magazine, against Raith Rovers on Saturday, May 2.

Alloa Athletic 3 Dumbarton 0

“SOMETIMES you need a result like Saturday’s in order to kick start you again.”

Manager Ian Murray’s comments in the press conference following Dumbarton’s 2-1 defeat to Hibernian on Wednesday.

So does anyone have a set of jump leads?

Because even though Sons are officially Scotland’s best part-time side for a third year in a row, here we are again.

Just when you thought the nightmare at Cowdenbeath was a one-off, it manifested itself again at Alloa only seven days later.

Iain Flannigan and Kevin Cawley scored long distance effort to give the Wasps – who hadn’t beaten Sons in the previous 15 attempts – a 2-0 lead in 20 minutes.

The visitors did have chances but similarly were lucky that Greig Spence’s goal for Alloa was only their third. They could have gone down by a bigger margin.

Games like these do happen in isolation. And of course, Dumbarton have already done well to achieve their two biggest goals of the season.

Staying up was done with a remarkable six games to spare, and Cowdenbeath’s 2-1 defeat at home to Livingston on Saturday meant the part-time title was won again.

But lifeless, insipid performances like this one two Saturdays on the bounce? Whatever the circumstances, not acceptable.

The Hibs defeat was definitely unlucky, but the displays on either side of it were far from being hallmarks of Scotland’s leading part-time side.

Crunch time is approaching where players’ futures are concerned and manager Ian Murray may yet have to be convinced by a few of his squad. Games like this do no-one any favours in that respect.

And even if a place in the 2015/16 Championship is secured, the fans don’t deserve to travel across Scotland twice in seven days to see Sons outplayed by teams below them.

Within minutes at the Indodrill Stadium, the warning signs were there, with Liam Buchanan’s shot deflected wide.

But on seven minutes, after Scott Agnew fouled Ryan McCord, Iain Flannigan found the net with a fine 20-yard free kick.

Michael Chopra also went close for Alloa, while Scott Agnew, playing his 150th game for Sons, shot narrowly wide in response.

However, after 20 minutes Cawley blasted home from distance. Alloa had the wind advantage in the first half and were really making use of it.

Buchanan was to narrowly miss another twice before the half was out, firstly with a header blocked at close range, and then a low drive which went past the far post.

In between those, Archie Campbell’s shot for Sons went wide, while Jordan Kirkpatrick’s shot narrowly missed the target.

With the wind in their favour in the second half, there still looked to be something in this game for Dumbarton.

But it took until the 68th minute for them to go close, as Agnew’s free kick from out wide was saved.

Danny Rogers then did brilliantly to save Spence’s overhead kick, but on 71 minutes the striker did get the better of him.

After meeting Darryl Meggatt’s cross ahead of the Sons keeper, Spence had a simple headed finish into an empty net.

Rogers then did brilliantly to save from McCord, while at the other end Dylan Easton’s shot from six yards was deflected off target.

And that was really all there was. Both teams went through the motions for the final stages and Alloa could celebrate the same result as Cowdenbeath claimed last Saturday.

As for Dumbarton – not much to say that couldn’t be said at Central Park. Not much to say that COULD be said after the Hibs game. This wasn’t even half of what they produced in that one.

It’s only Rangers next, chasing second place.

Sons put in a performance against a team of promotion candidates last Wednesday. Maybe they’ll do so again.

Alloa Athletic: Gibson; Gordon, Meggatt, Cawley, McCord, Holmes, Benedictus, Flannigan (Ferguson 86), Doyle, Buchanan (Layne 89), Chopra (Spence 57). Subs: McDowall; Asghar, Rutherford, Roberts.

Dumbarton: Rogers; Graham, Gilhaney (Megginson 71), Agnew, Kirkpatrick, Taggart (Linton 71), Fleming, Petrie (Easton 55), Findlay, Campbell, Wilson. Subs: Ewings; McCallum, Lightbody. Booked: Findlay.

Referee: Kevin Graham.

Crowd: 535.

From fame to frustration

Please note that ALL content on The Dumbarton Terrace is copyright and may not be reproduced in any form without the author’s prior permission.

HE looked as if he’d put Dumbarton the road to a famous result.

But within nine minutes, Mitch Megginson’s goal was simply one back for Sons against Hibernian.

And that was how it stayed, as the Edinburgh club recorded a 2-1 win away to a battling Dumbarton side.

The goalscorer admitted after the game that the players knew they owed the fans a performance after Saturday’s 3-0 defeat at Cowdenbeath.

They certainly produced that, but the sending off of Chris Turner in a controversial match made life more difficult.

Mitch admitted: “We’re gutted. We deserved at least a point.

“We had chances, but going down to 10 men made it hard for us. We did really well even after that and still created a few opportunities.

“We all knew that Saturday’s performance wasn’t up to our usual standards and we owed it to ourselves, and the fans who travelled, to play well tonight.

“It’s my second goal of the season against Hibernian, so I seem to do well against them. It’s enjoyable to play against them, Rangers and Hearts and a nice bonus to get on the scoresheet.

“I heard that Danny Rogers was blocked as the corner came in for the first goal, but I was watching the ball so couldn’t say.

“And when Chris was sent off I was facing the other way, so again I can’t comment on what happened.”

Sons now head to Alloa on Saturday to face a home side who will be right up for the game.

Having now appointed Danny Lennon as their new manager, the Wasps are desperate for the points after relegation rivals Cowdenbeath and Livingston both won last night.

But with Dumbarton unbeaten in 15 games against Alloa, Mitch insists the trip will be made in high spirits.

He added: “We’ve a good record against Alloa, but we know there’s a lot in it for them.

“They’ll be right up for it with their new manager and the fact that it’s a must-win game for them.

“They will want the points in their battle against the drop, but we will not go there and roll over.

“We know we need to work hard as our aim is still to be the best part-time team in Scotland, so we just need to go there full of confidence.

“And hopefully there can be another goal in it for me as well.”

What a difference!

Please note that ALL content on The Dumbarton Terrace is copyright and may not be reproduced in any form without the author’s prior permission.

FOUR days earlier, closer to his Edinburgh home, he was a disappointed and frustrated man.

But Ian Murray’s trip along the M8 last night was one of satisfaction, despite Dumbarton’s 2-1 defeat to Hibernian.

Sons produced a performance which was night and day to the Saturday’s 3-0 reverse at Cowdenbeath.

Ultimately it wasn’t enough, but the gaffer was happy enough with the response his players produced.

The task against Hibs was made even harder with the sending off of Chris Turner 12 minutes after half time.

However, Ian said: “We were outstanding. We played some really good stuff and worked incredibly hard.

“I said to the players that we got what we deserved on Saturday, but we didn’t tonight. Sometimes you need a performance like Saturday’s to kick start you again.

“We scored at a great time, when we were well on top of the game, and had numerous chances.

“We were thinking we could go on and win the game, and then we had the sending off.

“He has apologised for his actions. Chris is a player who plays on the edge and he was contributing massively to the game, but will now have a suspension to serve.

“It’s a red card all day long, but the Hibs player should have gone as well.

“Had we kept 11 men on the park, we would have had a chance, but it’s gone now.

“It’s not a penalty earlier in the game either, but there’s no point in speaking about it because you don’t get any answers.

“In any event, it was a great save from Danny Rogers and a real kick for us. However, it was disappointing to lose the goal just before half time from a set play.”

Now it is on to Alloa on Saturday, without the suspended Turner.

The Wasps – now under Danny Lennon’s management – are in desperate need of the points after last night’s results.

But Ian is demanding a repeat performance from his players, and his hoping for a greater reward this time around.

He added: “It’s a massive game for the league and a big one for us. If we play like that I am sure there will be a result in it for us.

“But if we play as we did against Cowdenbeath, we WILL lose.”

Dumbarton 1 Hibernian 2

Please note that ALL content on The Dumbarton Terrace is copyright and may not be reproduced in any form without the author’s prior permission.

EPISODE 12 of 13. Another hard luck story.

For 57 minutes, it looked like Dumbarton really could pick up a victory against one of the Championship’s ‘big three’ sides.

It was followed by seven minutes of uncertainty, and then the remaining 26 where, in reality, it wasn’t meant to be.

Against Hibernian, Sons were night and day from Saturday’s horror defeat by Cowdenbeath. The 1-0 half time deficit, to Paul Hanlon’s goal for the visitors, was harsh.

But there was little doubt an equaliser would come, and it did so 10 minutes after the restart from Mitch Megginson.

Unfortunately the sending off of Chris Turner, following a full and frank discussion with Hibs defender Jordon Forster, changed the game.

And when Jason Cummings put away the visitors’ second goal after 64 minutes, Sons were right up against it.

They tried and tried, and were more than a match for the promotion chasers, but the task proved too much.

The game was also the latest instalment of Craig Charleston’s comedy refereeing career in charge of Sons.

The whistler has a history of dodgy decisions against Dumbarton pretty much all through his senior career – and didn’t disappoint here either.

Turner’s sending off was absolutely clearcut, but Forster could easily have joined him for a bad tackle and his part in the alteraction.

Hanlon’s goal also came after at least two fouls in the Sons area, and had it not been for a magnificent save by Danny Rogers, a ludicrous penalty decision could also have cost Dumbarton.

That came with the game goalless when Scott Agnew ‘fouled’ Liam Craig, but Rogers produced an outstanding stop.

Match officials this season have ranged from efficient to incompetent, but Charleston is consistently poor. And has been for some time – although at least he gets something for consistency.

His red card victim had the first chance of the night on 10 minutes, with Turner’s volley being deflected wide after Andy Graham’s header fell to him.

Hibs’ first opportunity, on 17 minutes, was a real escape for Sons, with El Alagui connected with Martin Boyle’s low ball six yards out. Somehow, he shot over.

Despite the expectancy that Hibs would dominate Dumbarton wouldn’t go away. Stuart Findlay had a shot scrambled clear while Mark Gilhaney’s shot was turned wide at close range. The visitors’ response was a Cummings shot which hit the side netting.

Then, nine minutes from half time, Charleston’s first major gaffe was to award a penalty after Craig went down under Agnew’s challenge.

El Alagui stepped up, but after Rogers turned the ball on to the post, it rolled along the line and was cleared.

But seven minutes later he was beaten – not necessarily fairly.

Both he and Findlay, at the back post, looked to be fouled as a corner came in and Hanlon put the ball away. The only thing the officials were giving was a goal.

However, Sons had already made enough of an impression for everyone to know they could fight back. And of all people, the player leading the second half charge was right back Scott Taggart.

His shot from 20 yards was parried by the keeper, with the rebound cleared. Taggart then tried again almost immediately, and again Mark Oxley kept his shot out. Archie Campbell tried to cross the loose ball, but Oxley touched the ball away.

From the resulting corner, Andy Graham’s effort was cleared off the line by Scott Allan.

But on 55 minutes Sons were level – again as a result of Taggart’s attacking efforts.

His shot once again could not be held by Oxley, and Megginson snapped up the loose ball. Game on.

For all of 120 seconds. Then it tilted in Hibs’ favour.

Turner, in fine form all night, was hit by a robust challenge from Forster. His response of an attempted headbutt was not clever and deserved its punishment.

Still Sons drove forward, with Gilhaney laying off Megginson on the edge of the area only for the goalscorer to shoot over.

However, when Cummings put away a low ball from the left on 64 minutes, Sons had an even bigger mountain to climb.

And if a midweek shift wasn’t getting the better of them, the reduction in numbers was.

El Alagui missed two further chances while Fraser Fyvie also missed the target. An angled shot by Allan looked dangerous, but it too was wide.

Rogers did brilliantly to keep Fyvie out in the final minutes, and then turned El Alagui’s shot on to the post.

Dumbarton may have been beaten – but more than did their bit to ensure a hugely enjoyable 90 minutes.

They still need two points to be sure of the title of Scotland’s best part-time team. Alloa stand between them and that accolade on Saturday, having been well beaten by Hearts last night.

If Sons turn up and replicate this performance, the Wasps will find it very difficult to get the points they need.

Dumbarton: Rogers; Graham, Turner, Gilhaney (Kirkpatrick 72), Agnew, Megginson (Linton 82), Taggart, Fleming, Findlay, Campbell (Easton 87), Wilson. Subs: Grindlay; McCallum, Petrie, Lightbody. Booked: Graham. Sent off: Turner.

Hibernian: Oxley; Hanlon, Fontaine, Forster, Robertson (Fyvie 46), El Alagui, Craig, Stevenson, Boyle, Allan, Cummings (Malonga 80). Subs: Cerny; Stanton, Handling, Djejde, Dunsmore. Booked: Forster.

Referee: Craig Charleston.

Crowd: 1,110.